
There was enough hype around this film to make me walk into the theatre with high expectations. They were, however, met only halfway. For a long time, I couldn’t make up my mind about the film and kept oscillating between “Meh” and “Whoa!”.
A strong subject, a gutsy business move (making a female the central character in a mainstream masala film in a disgustingly patriarchal Hindi film industry) and decent production design (the way Vidya’s bra strap shows through her blouse pre-transformation was one of the many production #wins) got it a thumbs up. Vidya performed particularly well in the part of the film where she starts descending into alcoholism. Her make up in the late second half, with all that weight on her face was fairly convincing as well.
But the film remained full of could-have-beens. For starters, there was the stainless steel box that young Silk escapes the village with. You see it around more than twice in the first 45 minutes or so of the film. It had great “blankie” potential. It could have served as a symbol of the past she left behind, something to seek security in after the make up and the lights were off. But it just vanishes. Later in the film it is revealed that she ran away the night before her wedding. Wouldn’t it have been a lot more powerful had this been established right in the beginning? A case of bad editing?

Also, the woman who moves in with Silk in her new palatial home is conveniently dispensed with, without explanation, when she is to be shown struggling with loneliness. Why?
For the most part, Silk is shown as a victim of lecherous men and a misogynistic industry that wants to use her. Her relationship with Keedamal, however, is much more complex. He is the only one who is depicted as someone who sees her as nothing more than a professional. She shares a comfort and camaraderie with him that she shares with no other man in the film. Could that not have been explored a little more?
In the award ceremony sequence, it appears that Nyla (Anju Mahendroo is getting horribly typecast playing the rich bitch), despite not liking Silk’s aesthetic and her kind of cinema, admires her courage - and tells her as much. She later even calls her the only “hero” in the industry. Why then, is Silk shown to be so hostile to her? The scene where Silk literally stops traffic outside Nyla’s house with her mere presence (reminiscent of this real life episode) - though well directed, was somewhat unjustifiable.
After the good and the ugly, now the bad.
Tushar Kapoor has to be the biggest mistake in the film. The stainless steel container from the initial scenes of the film would’ve done a better job playing Ramakanth. And no sweetie, dropping the “Kapoor” from your name won’t help.
Emraan Hashmi did marginally better in the acting department. Though in the scene where he beats up his assistant director, the way he says “You horny bastard!” made yours truly squirm in her seat and demand her money back. The otherwise fast-paced film began crawling after Abraham (Emraan) begins to think favuorably of Silk. There is a romantic song - complete with background dancers and the works that randomly pops out of nowhere. I thought we stopped doing that after 2005. I just told myself they were trying to be meta about “having to” use trade tricks like these to make a film sell - like they did in the films in the film.
The scene where Silk realises that Abraham has begun liking her, she says to herself -yes, to herself - “Ab to tere dushman bhi tujhse khafa nahin hain”. A huge aberration in the otherwise normal behaviour of her character. It wouldn’t have been so cringeworthy had she not been given any lines whatsoever for this scene.
So should you watch The Dirty Picture at all? Yes. Watch it for Vidya and Naseeruddin. It’s actually pretty entertaining. And Vidya, as she puts it in the film, is entertainment herself.
Note: Since I know very little of Silk Smitha and her life, I will refrain from commenting on how faithfully it represented her. Both images used here are stolen off the interwebz and I claim no ownership of them.